skip to main content
 
 
 
News
In the News
Sep 23, 2019

Loretta Merritt in the Law Times on the recent ruling in Ontario court that a cap on general damages does not apply to sexual abuse

Share:
Law Times View original

The Ontario Superior Court has awarded general damages in excess of the cap in a sexual assault case, a first for the province, say lawyers.

Known as the trilogy, three cases from the late 1970s – Andrews v. Grand and Toy Alberta Limited, Thornton v. District No. 57 and Arnold v. Teno – established that plaintiffs could not recover more than $350,000 (adjusted for inflation) for non-pecuniary damages as the result of a catastrophic personal injury.

In D.S. v. Quesnelle, Justice Clyde Smith awarded $400,000 to a man repeatedly sexually assaulted by Louis Omer Quesnelle between 1987 and 1992. In a criminal trial, Quesnelle was convicted in 2013 and sentenced to five years in prison.

The nature of the assaults in D.S. v. Quesnelle made it “the worst of the worst cases,” says Loretta Merritt, a lawyer at Torkin Manes LLP, whose practice focuses on historical sexual abuse.

In awarding damages for pain and suffering, courts consider the age, vulnerability and subsequent impact of the plaintiff; the number, frequency and nature of the assaults and whether the respondent was in a position of trust, Merritt says. At the time of the abuse, the plaintiff was between five and 10, there were numerous, serious assaults and the assaults were “as invasive and degrading as they could be,” she says.

This article originally appeared in the Law Time. Visit the Law Times to read the complete article. 

Related News

In the News

Loretta Merritt speaks to CTV News about Gordon Stuckless release

Loretta P. Merritt Hamilton residents and members of city council are reacting to news that convicted sex offender, Gordon Stuckless, is living in a halfway house in the...
Jan 16, 2020
Firm News

Torkin Manes partners with #JLFToronto2019 to bring internationally acclaimed authors to the stage

Torkin Manes is proud to be a Festival Partner for #JLFToronto2019 held September 27-29 in Toronto’s historic Distillery District. Uniting inter...
Sep 30, 2019

Torkin Manes named Regional Law Firm of the Year at the 2019 Chambers Canada Awards

Torkin Manes is proud to announce that our firm has been recognized as the Regional Law Firm of the Year by Chambers and Partners at the 201...
Sep 17, 2019